As I am finding myself constantly bombarded with criticism (helpful, friendly, constructive, but sometimes vague...), I was wondering how you would criticise some pieces by famous composers if I uploaded them. I think this thread will comfort those who feel their compositions are never good enough. Even the best make mistakes. :) Be truthful and criticise all you want! The composers are dead. :P

The first song... hrm! How about... Winter by Vivaldi? :)

You're gonna have to try harder to get me to say something bad about Vivaldi. Winter is my favourite of the Four Seasons. Put some of Berlioz's Requiem on here. I'll go to town.

Everyone's a critic -_- ...constructive ones are great couse ppl are actually trying to help...however too much of that can be very discouraging... :(

anywayz about this peice...

the repetitive beginning (and all the other repetitions throughout this entire peice) might turn off people that don't have patience to hear the whole song (like me for instance....i miss out on alot of excellent song that way :lol:) of course this being a midi i can't really comment on the dynamics and playing can i :heh:

Winter's my fav season too, i lov playing in the snow... :sweatdrop:

PS: i actually listened to the whole peice ^.^ even though we are suppose to critic....ME WANT TO SAY I LOV THIS SONG

I want to criticize...but I don't know how I should put it.