Ok I made a new song in about 5-10 minutes, expressing my sadness and distaste in Noir7 and his compositions, enjoy, my Padawans.

Since you get to speak your mind, I guess I can speak my own too.

This sucks.

Learn to write music, and say shit about people and peopl's creations to yourself.

The song has no structure, and is way to fucking repeditive with that back-up.

That left hand was stupid. I'm surprized it actually took you that long to 'write' this.

And I know you said 5-10 mins. to make people think that you can write any good song in a matter of a few minutes.

What ^ said.

I mean, it had a little bit structure, but... :heh: Anyways, the drums could be worked on. By the way, that wasn't an ending, was it? XD Also, I must agree that it did get a little repetitive. Maybe adding more instruments would've helped, though I think it might still get on my nerves.

As you go on, you'll get better. ;) Don't worry, you'll improve - just don't talk shit about anyone's compositions, because Noir7 is an excellent composer, and his songs are much more organized and well... nice to listen to. ^_^ Learn to accept that when you're starting, the more experienced ones will have the upper hand and you should look to them for help, if not: What the hell are doing here?! XD

All I can say...

Right O

XD You still here?

Wow, speak of bad musicianship... And for your song, don't need to listen to it, because I am gonna give you -10/10. Grow up and learn to take some criticisms.

It's ok. I expected as much, defending your kind, talentless hacks. And you said something about good, unbiased criticism? My ass. You're just jealous, admit it. Poor babies :) ;)

You people are animals, not intelligent enough to be considered human. It's like poke one wasp, and the entire swarm attacks you. Stop being followers, and develop minds of your own you drones ;) *slices everyone up with lightsaber*

This proves noir7 is some snot-nosed kid who depends on others for defense, and can't take the heat. This is fun :D Keep it up

Yes, 18 year old lion king fanboy, stop being such a woman, Noir. Oh, I can feel it! Here comes the big pms attack! lol

Welcome, everyone, to the dark side of the force!!!

Telentless hacks? Ok.. you have no idea who the fuck I am you little punk. I am 14 years old.

I worked on a School Band/Piano Arrangement to be played at our last concert with music from great Movie Score professionals.. worked on and made this arrangemnt in 3 months.

I played with the band only a week... I had a standing ovation-twice on our concert night. I was flooded with applause for at least 5 or more minutes. I was commented that night; comments after another and another. Even after the concert, people at school were talking to me about the concert, and how my song was so great...

Oh yea, just to be an ass..

I only played piano for 5 months before I attempteds Beethoven's Fur Elise.. I know it's easy, but people usually play for about 2 years then attempt that. This March, I got a perfect score on that.

ANd now I am working on songs that are more professional (Beethoven's Pathetique sonata, Lisztss Liebestraume, some of Chopin's Prelude, Etude No. 3 from Liszt's 12 Etudes d'Execution Transcendentals.)

Dude, fuck off, and get off our forums.

I was a little pissed when Noir bashed my compositions.. thing was, I was over and done with it in a week. Ask anyone here.

I have built my respect up to say this.. so cherish in MINE and OUR glory-not your little punk ass 4 yr old crying baby ways.

Telentless hacks? Ok.. you have no idea who the fuck I am you little punk. I am 14 years old.

I worked on a School Band/Piano Arrangement to be played at our last concert with music from great Movie Score professionals.. worked on and made this arrangemnt in 3 months.

I played with the band only a week... I had a standing ovation-twice on our concert night. I was flooded with applause for at least 5 or more minutes. I was commented that night; comments after another and another. Even after the concert, people at school were talking to me about the concert, and how my song was so great...

Oh yea, just to be an ass..

I only played piano for 5 months before I attempteds Beethoven's Fur Elise.. I know it's easy, but people usually play for about 2 years then attempt that. This March, I got a perfect score on that.

ANd now I am working on songs that are more professional (Beethoven's Pathetique sonata, Lisztss Liebestraume, some of Chopin's Prelude, Etude No. 3 from Liszt's 12 Etudes d'Execution Transcendentals.)

Dude, fuck off, and get off our forums.

I was a little pissed when Noir bashed my compositions.. thing was, I was over and done with it in a week. Ask anyone here.

I have built my respect up to say this.. so cherish in MINE and OUR glory-not your little punk ass 4 yr old crying baby ways.

Nevertheless, your compositions still suck. Your school must have low standards ;) (repetitious crap+cheap transpositions) You can't fool me.

If you can play an instrument doesn't mean you can compose, little girl.

Oh, and with your miniscule brain capacity, if I was you, I'd run all the posts through spellcheck before submitting.
You, "Maestro," are pretty worthless, Seth Fag-Gengler.

Oh wow, I know my compositions aren't good... but this is horrible. And since all of us says that is sucks - it sucks so don't deny it. Although this is the first time I heard a deaf person compose... good try though.

ALL HAIL NOIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Btw, you're no musician. Get out of here.

Oh wow, I know my compositions aren't good... but this is horrible. And since all of us says that is sucks - it sucks so don't deny it. Although this is the first time I heard a deaf person compose... good try though.

ALL HAIL NOIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Btw, you're no musician. Get out of here.
Neither are you.

That's all you have as a defense? What a loser you are. =S

Anyways, it's kinda weird but I like your Jedi one (vocal version) but this one sucked bad... how long have you been composing?

Nevertheless, your compositions still suck. Your school must have low standards ;) (repetitious crap+cheap transpositions) You can't fool me.

If you can play an instrument doesn't mean you can compose, little girl.

Oh, and with your miniscule brain capacity, if I was you, I'd run all the posts through spellcheck before submitting.
You, "Maestro," are pretty worthless, Seth Fag-Gengler.

ROFLAMORLFMAORLMDOAFMOMLAFOEMFLOSMFOELMAOFLEMOSLFO !

Low standards. Wow that made me burst out laughing! :lol: :lol:

Actually, my Band Teacher listened to the Rought Draft of it and saw all of it's potential. He's a high class composer, and has been in music for more than 40 years.

You should really WATCH or EXPLORE something before you say it. I also know it didnt suck, since over 2,000 people attended it and saw everyone of their faces with smileds and applause in their attitude and expression.

"STFU NOOB"

Also, I know if you can play an instrument, doesn't mean you can compose-but I am critiquing your piano composition/parts. They do not sound like something that would be found in Piano songs.

Oh yea, then again, your mind is clouded with Star WARS! OH I HAVE I LIFE! @_@

ROFLAMORLFMAORLMDOAFMOMLAFOEMFLOSMFOELMAOFLEMOSLFO !

Low standards. Wow that made me burst out laughing! :lol: :lol:

Actually, my Band Teacher listened to the Rought Draft of it and saw all of it's potential. He's a high class composer, and has been in music for more than 40 years.

You should really WATCH or EXPLORE something before you say it. I also know it didnt suck, since over 2,000 people attended it and saw everyone of their faces with smileds and applause in their attitude and expression.

"STFU NOOB"

Also, I know if you can play an instrument, doesn't mean you can compose-but I am critiquing your piano composition/parts. They do not sound like something that would be found in Piano songs.

Oh yea, then again, your mind is clouded with Star WARS! OH I HAVE I LIFE! @_@
You think WAY too highly of your music. You imagined everyone's reaction, people were simply being polite. I can't imagine anyone being wowed by your compositions, from what I heard.

Let's not go off-topic here. This thread is only about Sion and his compositions. If you still want to bitch at me, then fine, but don't start with the others.

Ty. Meh stops.

Let's not go off-topic here. This thread is only about Sion and his compositions. If you still want to bitch at me, then fine, but don't start with the others.
Maestro started with me, and this is fun so why don't you join us?
Misery loves company <3

Grow up.

Grow up.

Yes.

I did not like this composition as much as ur first. Perhapes if u spent more time on it or something.

Always fun to ban a troll :mellow:

I had a feeling that he was someone's dupe account, so that's why I didn't ban him right away. I wanted more time to determine if this was the case or not =P Since IP searching didn't give anything...

but meh, it was probably for the better. *locks*